Top of Sidebar
Mission Statement
Do It Yourself Tips and Tricks
Books, Equipment, Software, and Training Reviews
Film Critiques
Community Section
Savings and Links
Editorials
Archives
Bottom of Sidebar
Back to the Home Page
Rough Cut Critique: Slumber Party, Pg. 3

Use of Audio
The R&B soundtrack for the movie is great. It sounds awesome, flows well, and fits the various scenes appropriately. Several of the rappers featured on the soundtrack are also actors in the movie, which is a nice touch.

However, the soundtrack was the only stable audio in the movie. I had to keep the remote on hand while I was watching the movie; the audio is uneven, constantly shifting in pitch, volume, and intensity from scene to scene all throughout the film. Part of the problem was the changing environments (indoors, outdoors, etc.), and part of it was not adequately checking the audio before shooting. Now, having been produced a micro-cinema film, I know how hard it is to get decent audio; ours was so bad, we had to go back and re-dub all of the actors' voices in post-production! While I don't recommend that for every film, I would suggest it as a consideration. Personally, I think that this movie would greatly benefit from cleaning up the audio with ADR (automatic dialogue replacement).

There are also a few scenes where the girls are partying in the house, dancing to music from a stereo. Rather than have the music from the stereo blend into the background, it ends up overriding the dialogue so you can't hear what's being said. The same thing happens with multiple-conversation scenes; people end up talking over one another so that you can't hear what anyone is saying. Again, re-recording the dialogue in post would've made it easier to raise different characters' voices over music or other voices so the audience could hear what's going on.

LA Celebrity rapper Tha'
Realest and...
...Drive Time DJs Tha' Goodfellas
are some of the cameos in this film.

Use of Budget
As stated above, it's evident that this movie was filmed using a decent camera. But if a good quality camera is part of a movie, then good audio is an even greater part. I know from experience that it's not always possible to get great audio while you're shooting. However, doing ADR in post--while time-consuming--is well worth the time, effort, and money. It can completely change the feel of a film.

For $15,000, the movie was okay. However, for another, say, $5,000, the audio could have been re-dubbed; then they'd have a $20,000 movie that was even better. (A note to the filmmakers: I noticed that some of your cameos were professional rappers. If they're sympathetic to your film, they might be able to gain access to a studio to redub the film when the studio isn't in use for a much lower cost or even no cost. We will be doing some articles on good redubbing in future issues, but if you decide to do this before then, email me and I can give you some specific advice ahead of time.)

Finally, since they decided to distribute via DVD, a last thing that needed to be considered in the budget is how the DVD printing was going to be done and what was going to be on it.

They've gotten some awesome graphic designing done for the DVD covers and the DVDs themselves, plus they even put in a bloopers and outtakes on the DVD. However, it doesn't have any chapters in it. This means that no one can flip to a scene that they want to show their friends, which in turn means less people who will see scenes from the film and wish to go purchase it. Along those same lines, I noticed that they have a trailer on their website, yet in the Collector's Edition of your DVD, it was noticeably absent. They went to all the work of creating the trailer, why not put it on the DVD so people can show friends who might be interested in watching the film?

Lasting Appeal
The movie and the production company that made it have a lot of potential. There really aren't enough good urban comedy movies, and I would like to see that void start to be filled. Hopefully microfilmmakers like the women in Xyrus will start tackling that genre.

Having said that, I must honestly say that as the movie is now I would not show it to my friends. Not because the film isn't funny or my friends don't like this type of comedy. Rather it is because of three major drawbacks: unstable audio, adlibbed dialogue, and loose scripting. These three aspects affected the entire impact of the movie; they influenced the acting, the humor, character interaction, and understanding of the plot. These three features could have all been improved by good post-production cleanup, sticking to the script, and tighter writing.

Overall Comment
Slumber Party has the markings of a humorous and creative urban comedy. Unfortunately, structural problems (dialogue and scripting) and technical problems (audio and lighting) made it difficult for the audience to fully understand or appreciate it. (And there are few things worse than your audience not understanding your film!)

Not to despair though, this is only the first movie these talented young ladies have put out. The first start is always the roughest, and it's only through experience that we improve.

 
Content            
      6.0         
Visual Look            
      5.0         
Use of Audio            
3.0         
Use of Budget            
6.0         
           Lasting Appeal            
           3.0         
Overall Score           
  4.6         



Mission | Tips & Tricks | Equipment & Software Reviews | Film Critiques
Groups & Community | Links & Savings
| Home


Contact Us Search Submit Films for Critique