Top of Sidebar
Mission Statement
Do It Yourself Tips and Tricks
Books, Equipment, Software, and Training Reviews
Film Critiques
Community Section
Savings and Links
Editorials
Archives
Bottom of Sidebar
Back to the Home Page
Final Critique: The Changeling, Pg. 2

Visual Look
It is a rather daunting task to attempt a period production on a microcinema budget, mainly because the location, props, makeup, and costumes must be appropriate to the time in which the story takes place. They did do a pretty darn good job with the location and props; the only thing that seemed a little off was that the costumes--while well done considering the budget--were more reflective of the mid-to-late1800's than the Elizabethan Era. Then again, they could have purposely set the play out of its original time, much like Kenneth Branagh's or Ethan Hawke's productions of Hamlet.

Another tricky area with period films is that they frequently deal with odd lighting situations, specifically things like torches, kerosene lamps, candles, and fireplaces. This is no exception. However, in all of the different light conditions-- daylight, nighttime, flickering indoor light, etc.--the gaffing was done well and consistently. Also, the editing, while simple, was well done and appropriate to the piece.

While there the director uses
several creative POV shots...
...most of the two-person dialogue
scenes are from only one angle.

The one area that really could have used improvement is the one area that's impossible to fix in post: the camera work.

When the audience is having to pay so much attention to what's being said in order to understand what's going on, one of the most distracting things is a shaky camera. There was quite a bit of camera shake, especially during Act II. This could be fixed for future productions with a homemade steadicam rig (see our article on how to make your own here or here).

There were also several long scenes that had just one or two angles. It would have been nice to break up these scenes (such as the exchange between Beatrice and Alsemero in Act I) with additional shots, like an over-the-shoulder shot, inverse close up, or some use of depth perspective, etc. Also, utilizing movement (either by using the aforementioned steadicam or by having the actors walk or move around) is also very useful. This does not have to be done all the time, but is effective when used every so often.

These camera issues were largely due to the fact that the film had to be shot in only six days, which resulted in some run-and-gun style decisions. It's impressive that so much was able to be accomplished in only six days, yet a longer shooting schedule for future productions would alleviate most of these problems.

Use of Audio
The audio was a bit on the soft side, which can be remedied by setting dialogue to -12 Db, background music to -18 Db, and full music to -12 Db in post. (Sound effects are a bit louder, but they can be adjusted easily enough once you have the other settings in place.) Once I had turned my sound system up a bit, the volume stayed pretty much even throughout the film.

I did notice that in the exchange between Beatrice and De Flores in Act II, his dialogue was a bit softer and harder to hear than hers. Also, the scene where Beatrice is convincing Diaphanta to take her place, the maid's dialogue is a bit too loud and over-the-top for her performance, which makes me think it was re-dubbed in post. A little more mixing of the audio levels in post can help fix these additional issues.

Music, as I am discovering, is probably the second most powerful tool in moviemaking. A character might say or do something cruel, but if the music in the background is playful and light, we are more apt to write off the cruelty as something funny; by contrast, if the same person says something funny but dark, ominous music plays, we begin to suspect him or her. This is especially important when the audience has to put forth extra effort to understand what is happening and being said. For this reason, there really needed to be more appropriate music in the background when action or dialogue was taking place. While there was music, it seemed too simple in contrast with the tone and themes of the film.

[Note to the Director: If more streamlined music composition isn't available, we just reviewed a program designed to create scored background music that combines the simplicty of loops with actually organically created music. The music it creates and customizes sounds really good and it's designed for video people, rather than audio people. The program is called SonicFire Pro 4 and you can click here to read the review.]

Mission | Tips & Tricks | Equipment & Software Reviews | Film Critiques
Groups & Community | Links & Savings
| Home


Contact Us Search Submit Films for Critique