Top of Sidebar
Mission Statement
Do It Yourself Tips and Tricks
Books, Equipment, Software, and Training Reviews
Film Critiques
Community Section
Savings and Links
Editorials
Archives
Bottom of Sidebar
Back to the Home Page
Final Short Critique: Broken, Pg. 3

Use of Audio
The music in Broken is strangely chilling and compelling, decidedly off-putting with just a touch of an industrial bondage effect. The dialogue recording is excellent with only one part of one line that was a bit too soft, and that seemed to only be due to the fact that it was uttered into Bonnie's hair by Duncan.

The sound effects are quite good for virtually all the film, with excellent gunfire Read ReviewPurchase_link sounds throughout. The only time the effects were off is at a key point in the film when Christian fires a shotgun and the effect that was used sounded like it had been recorded in an aluminum tunnel, with pinging highs and not enough bass for realism.

Use of Budget
The use of budget in this film is simply phenomenal. To make it even more astounding, according to producer Jorge Rodriguez, much of the budget of this film didn't go to light rental, camera rental, effects, gun purchasing, or costumes, rather much of the film's budget went to food and beverages. The film was shot in Florida in the basement of an un-ventilated, dilapidated hospital with actors wearing hot costumes doing their own stunts and production personnel having to scramble to shoot everything in five days, with all of them working under hot lights. Keeping that in mind, they had to make sure their people were well fed and well hydrated so that no one passed out in the midst of all this.

Little touches like this
bloody throwing blade...
...and this night-vision scope display
really look amazing.

Lasting Appeal
I've seen this short over ten times and I notice something new each time. While it does not answer almost any of the questions it raises, it definitely makes you appreciate what these young filmmakers accomplished for our art and makes you look forward to seeing a full-length feature.

Overall Comment
An excellent first film, this short breaks down the barriers of what can be accomplished in the realm of action and suspense at the micro-budget level. As other filmmakers build on the work of Mr. Ferrari, Mr. Rodriguez, Mr. Falcon, and all the other folks that made this film possible, this may prove to be one of the most inspirational short films for our cause in quite some time!

(If you haven't checked it out, go to our review of the Broken DVD and read it.)

 
Content            
      7.0         
Visual Look            
      9.0         
Use of Audio            
9.0         
Use of Budget            
10.0         
           Lasting Appeal            
           9.0         
Overall Score           
  8.8         

Mission | Tips & Tricks | Equipment & Software Reviews | Film Critiques
Groups & Community | Links & Savings
| Home


Contact Us Search Submit Films for Critique