Top of Sidebar
Mission Statement
Do It Yourself Tips and Tricks
Books, Equipment, Software, and Training Reviews
Film Critiques
Community Section
Savings and Links
Editorials
Archives
Bottom of Sidebar
Back to the Home Page
   Short Film Critique: 
   Who’s Ma Ma! Joe Ma Ma!

   Director: Sean J.S. Jourdan
   Expected Rating: R due to language
   Distribution: None
   Budget: Less than $500
   Genre: Documentary/Short

   Running Time: 13 minutes

   Release Dates: February 15, 2007
   Website: http://www.seanjsjourdan.com
   Trailer: None
   Review Date: July 1, 2007
   Reviewed By: Monika DeLeeuw-Taylor

Final Score:
6.9
How do we critique films? Click Here To See.

To quote a recent commercial, “Having a baby changes everything.”

Take the most hardened, disagreeable, and roughhousing man and place his newborn baby in his arms, and he will most likely break down and weep. This short film is a documentary of one such man, known by friends as Joe Ma Ma, a former badass biker dude, now a father and owner of a motorcycle repair shop. He spends his days at work, rehashing good days with his buddies, but the rest of the day belongs to his kids.

Former biker
dude Joe Ma Ma...
...Has given up his wild ways
in favor of his children.

Content
For a documentary, this film is very random. It opens with the title as a neon sign (which one later comes to realize is the name of Joe’s shop), then cuts to inside the shop where Joe is telling stories about the crazy things he did as a young man. The film cuts back and forth between Joe and his kids – as he helps build a pumpkin cart for his son – and his time at the motorcycle shop.

The problem with this random nature is that the audience spends half of the movie trying to figure out who and what the documentary is supposed to be about. And once one figures that out, the movie is nearly over. The characters should be introduced by some kind of narration – which could be done by Joe – or perhaps just by simple titles.

There is one touching story that Joe tells about a son who died at age 15 from sniffing glue. As he tells this story, he is holding a photograph, but the audience never get a chance to see it. A quick cutaway to the photograph there – and perhaps to other photos of Joe as a younger man – would give some more depth and weight to the story.

He now owns a
motorcycle repair shop...
...And reminisces
about days gone by.

Visual Look
The visuals of this film are quite decent. Inside the motorcycle shop is very well-lit, and the exteriors aren’t too bad, if a little bit washed out. The interior shots of Joe building his son’s pumpkin cart and of the Boy Scouts derby that follows have a bit of a yellowish tint to them that may have been caused by either improper white balancing or fluorescent lights.

There were a couple shaky camera moves, but as the entire style of the film was sort of run-and-gun that didn’t seem to be such a big deal. Though there was one shot where Joe and his son got into a pickup truck, and the cameraman squeezed in with them while still taping. The result was that the cameraman seemed to be pressed back against the passenger door so as to get both Joe and his son in the shot, but the shot looked far too tight. It may have been a better idea to just use different series of shots or, if the filmmakers really wanted a shot inside the truck, try to mount the camera in the dash instead. (Yeah, it’s rather tricky, but it is possible, and the final result looks pretty cool.)

Mission | Tips & Tricks | Equipment & Software Reviews | Film Critiques
Groups & Community | Links & Savings
| Home


Contact Us Search Submit Films for Critique